Lady Stoneheart vs Jon Snow

Potential Spoilers Below

After Jon remembers who and what he is and is able to recall the memories of Ser Arthur Dayne a similar scenario will ensue.  Jon will have a confrontation with the Brotherhood without Banners similar to that of the events of the Kingswood Brotherhood.

Jon Snow

Arthur Dayne

The Kingswood Brotherhood were outlaws in the Kingswood.  They kidnapped nobles and were such a problem that King Aerys II sent members of his Kingsguard to kill them.  Ser Arthur Dayne gained the confidence of the smallfork.  He didn't take from them and ensured that what they took was paid for.  The Smiling Knight as stated by Jaime Lannister was his generation's Ser Gregor Clegane in terms of men's eagerness to best him in combat.  The Smiling Knight and Jaime fought for a short time until Arthur Dayne took up the challenge.  Their first exchange ended when the Smiling Knight broke his sword  but Arthur paused the fight while The Smiling Knight took up a new sword.  The Smiling Night said that it was Dawn, Arthur's Sword, that he wanted.  Arthur replied with "Then you shall have it, ser."  The Smiling Night was killed during their second exchange.

King Aerys II

The Smiling Knight

Jaime Lannister

Gregor Clegane aka "The Mountain"

I believe Jon will do something similar with the Brotherhood Without Banners.  Jon will go in and befriend the smallfolk gaining their confidence.  After a time he will confront Lady Stoneheart.  Like the Smiling Knight her actions are beginning to make those around her think her to be insane.  She will name several champions to fight Jon in "trial by combat" Lady Stoneheart style.  Jon will win the sword fight, using Dawn aka Lightbringer, and she will tell the others to kill him when those who had been loyal to her will turn on her and kill her.  Thoros of Myr will refuse to bring her back.  Jon will enlist the Brotherhod Without Banners to his cause.

Lady Stoneheart

Thoros of Myr

To those of you who don't know who I believe Jon Snow is read the following articles:

Is Jon Snow really dead?

Jon Snow: Do the Prophecies Make the Man?

Daenerys Targaryen and Tyrion Lannister; the ties that bind

Comments encouraged.  Love to hear the idea’s of others.  Most believe that since I present my idea’s as “fact like” I’m not open to change my viewpoints which is far from the truth.  I simply look at the information presented and go from there.  If you can shine a light on another way of thinking that opens the door to debate.